Super-Ingenuity (SPI)

CNC Machining & Injection Molding — DFM/Moldflow Support, CMM Inspection, Prototype to Production Solutions.

ISO 9001 & IATF 16949 CERTIFIED
24h Quote · Free DFM/Moldflow Feedback · CMM Inspection Reports · Global Shipping
Get Instant Quote

CAD Ready: STEP, IGES, STL supported

Super Ingenuity Subcontract Processing Routing and Hard Chrome Plating Quality Inspection

Subcontract Processing Routing and Acceptance Form: Free Template, Checklist, and Inspection Guide

A subcontract processing routing and acceptance form is used to control outsourced tooling operations such as EDM electrode machining, hard chrome plating, and nitriding. It defines part identity, drawing revision, CTQ requirements, supplier instructions, and incoming acceptance criteria before assembly release.

Need to align outsourced processes with mold build requirements? Review the CTQ and supplier document section below.

What Is a Subcontract Processing Routing and Acceptance Form?

What the form does

01
Identifies the part and drawing revision
02
Defines outsourced process scope
03
Communicates CTQ features and protected areas
04
States incoming inspection criteria
05
Records accept / conditional accept / reject status

Why this form matters for outsourced tooling operations

Hard Chrome Plating quality inspection for mold components
  • Visual appearance alone is not enough: Surface aesthetics do not guarantee internal material integrity or precise coating thickness.
  • Evidence-based quality: Processes like plating, heat treatment, and nitriding require objective evidence (test reports) to confirm performance.
  • Hidden fit risks: Returned parts may look acceptable but fail critical fit, shutoff requirements, or dimensional report audits during assembly.

Value logic: A checklist provides structured acceptance and traceability, ensuring that special processes are accompanied by required documentation and physical verification.

Who typically uses this form

Tooling Engineer Mold Project Engineer Bench Lead Incoming Inspector Supplier Quality Engineer (SQE) Subcontract Coordinator

When Should You Use This Form?

Before Parts Are Sent to Outside Suppliers

  • EDM electrodes (verify datum & burn areas)
  • Hard chrome plated inserts
  • Nitrided cores and cavities
  • Heat-treated mold components
  • Outsourced wire EDM segments
  • Polishing or texturing on controlled surfaces
Pre-shipment inspection for mold components before DLC coating

When Returned Parts Come Back for Inspection

  • Quantity Verification: Match receipt vs. PO
  • Visual Condition: Check for handling damage
  • Dimensional Verification: Re-check CTQ fits
  • Process Report Review: Audit CoC & charts
  • Final Disposition: Accept, Reject, or Rework
Incoming inspection of mirror polished mold components
Engineering Reality Check

When a Spreadsheet Alone Is Not Enough

A basic logistics tracker (Part/Qty/Date) fails to capture critical engineering data:

  • Missing CTQ VerificationNo specific data on critical-to-quality dimensions.
  • Revision Traceability LossFails to link the process to the specific drawing rev.
  • Unprotected SurfacesNo instructions for masking or non-processed zones.
  • No Acceptance StandardsNo clear pass/fail criteria for the inspector.
  • Missing Required ReportsNo placeholder for mandatory CoC or test evidence.

What Should Be Included in the Form?

A high-standard routing form is more than a tracking sheet; it's a technical contract. Here are the 4 essential categories and 25+ critical fields your template must have.

Basic Routing Fields

Logistics
  • Form Number
  • Mold Number
  • Project Name
  • Supplier Name
  • Date Out
  • Required Return Date
  • Actual Return Date
  • Shipment Method

Part-Level Engineering

Technical
  • Part Name & ID
  • Quantity Sent
  • Base Material
  • Drawing Rev
  • Subcontract Process
  • CTQ Features
  • Tolerance Specs
  • Acceptance Std

Incoming Acceptance

Quality Gate
  • Qty Received
  • Visual Check
  • Dimensional Check
  • Process-Specific Check
  • Report Verification
  • Final Disposition
  • NCR Reference (if any)
  • Inspector Signature

Required Documents

Evidence
  • Cert. of Conformity (CoC)
  • Plating Thickness Report
  • Hardness Test Report
  • Case Depth Report
  • Dimensional Record
  • Heat Treat Cert.
  • Material Evidence
  • Process Data Logs

Free Download: Routing Form, Incoming Inspection Checklist, and Example Record

Get the complete toolkit used by professional mold shops to manage outsourced special processes. Standardize your quality data today.

What is included in the download pack

  • Editable Excel Form (.xlsx)
  • Printable PDF Form
  • Example Completed Record
  • Process-specific Checklist
  • Short Work Instruction (SOP)
  • CTQ Verification Guide

Who this template is for

  • Mold Shops
  • Tooling Teams
  • SQE / Inspection Teams
  • Outsourcing Buyers
Subcontracting documentation pack preview
File Details: 1.2MB .ZIP archive containing fully editable engineering assets.

Example Form Structure: Routing, CTQ, and Incoming Acceptance

Acceptance Criteria by Process

EDM Electrode Acceptance Checklist

  • Readable electrode ID: Permanent marking on datum face.
  • Protected burn face: No handling scratches or oxidation.
  • Correct datum orientation: Matches CAD setup.
  • Profile tolerance: Verified against inspection report.
  • No chipped edges: Sharp corners preserved on graphite/copper.
  • Fixture-ready: Seating faces clean and burr-free.
Inspection Item Requirement Check Method Reject Condition
Identification Unique ID per CAD Visual Missing/Wrong ID
Burn Face No visible defects 10x Magnifier Scratches > 0.02mm
Datums ±0.01mm Flatness Indicator/CMM Out of Tolerance

Hard Chrome Plating Acceptance Checklist

Hard chrome plating quality inspection for mold inserts
  • Plated area: Matches drawing specifications exactly.
  • Clean masking: Non-plated surfaces show no seepage.
  • Surface integrity: No peeling, pitting, or blistering.
  • Coating thickness: Verified by micron-gauge/report.
  • Final fit: Verified after process (no interference).
SQE Critical Point:

Hard chrome plating is often used for wear resistance or dimensional salvage. The key failure point is hydrogen embrittlement or masking leakage on functional fit surfaces. Always re-verify sliding clearances after plating.

Nitriding Acceptance Checklist

  • Hardness: Meets HRC/HV target per drawing.
  • Case Depth: Verified by coupon or report (e.g., 0.1-0.2mm).
  • Oxidation: No abnormal "white layer" or cracks.
  • Distortion: Critical datums re-measured after heat.
  • Shutoff Faces: Integrity check on sealing lands.
Evidence Requirements:

1. Nitriding furnace chart (Time/Temp/Gas flow).
2. Hardness test record (HV0.3 or similar).
3. Certificate of Conformity linking to Part ID.

Heat Treatment (Vacuum/Salt)

Verify hardness at 3 points; check for quench cracks; ensure tempering cycles are documented.

Texturing & Coating (DLC/TiN)

Inspect under high-intensity light; verify pattern consistency; check for "rainbow" edge defects.

Outsourced Grinding

Verify perpendicularity and parallelism; check for "burn marks" or chatter on functional faces.

Surface Finishing (Polishing)

Review Ra/Rz values; ensure no rounding of sharp shutoff edges or critical datum corners.

CTQ Features and Protected Areas to Define Before Parts Go Out

Mold component critical-to-quality features and masking areas

Common Failures This Form Helps Prevent

⚠️ RISK 01

Wrong drawing revision released to supplier

Using outdated CAD data for EDM or plating leads to immediate scrap of high-value components.

⚠️ RISK 02

Missing or mixed-up returned parts

High-volume electrode sets or small inserts are easily lost without a serialized routing and quantity log.

⚠️ RISK 03

Chrome plated on the wrong surface

Failure to define masking areas results in plating on fit diameters, requiring costly stripping or rework.

⚠️ RISK 04

Missing hardness or thickness reports

Without evidence of process compliance, the actual performance of nitriding or heat treat is unknown until failure.

⚠️ RISK 05

Returned part passes visual but fails fit

Dimensional growth from plating or distortion from heat treat is not caught until final assembly release.

⚠️ RISK 06

Shutoff damage found too late (T1)

Handling damage during transport or processing goes unnoticed, causing flash during the first mold trial.

Process Control Matrix: Failure Analysis Critical Points
Identified Failure Common Root Cause Routing Form Control Point
Process Deviation (Wrong Rev) Reliance on verbal instructions or old email threads. Mandatory Drawing Number and Revision field on release.
Dimensional Interference Plating build-up on critical fit surfaces not accounted for. Defined CTQ re-measurement after process completion.
Missing Technical Evidence Supplier omits CoC or test charts; buyer fails to audit. "Required Reports" checklist must be signed off by IQC.
Surface Damage / Scratches Inadequate protection or masking during transport/handling. Incoming visual inspection gate before parts reach the bench.
Shutoff Face Collapse Over-exposure during nitriding or improper heat treat. Specific masking instructions for sealing lands/shutoffs.

How to Inspect Returned Outsourced Parts

Standardized incoming inspection is the final gate to prevent non-conforming parts from reaching the assembly bench or mold trial. Follow this 6-step SOP for every subcontracted batch.

Step 01

Verify quantity and identification

Match the physical part count against the Packing List and PO. Confirm unique Part IDs or serialized laser markings match the routing form records.

Step 02

Check visual condition and handling damage

Perform a 100% visual audit. Look for transportation scratches, rust, oxidation, or chips on sharp edges, especially on EDM electrodes and polished faces.

Step 03

Verify CTQ dimensions and fit-related features

Use calibrated micrometers or CMM to re-measure defined Critical-to-Quality (CTQ) areas. Check sliding fits after plating or hole diameters after nitriding.

Step 04

Review process-specific reports

Audit the supplier's technical evidence. Ensure the Certificate of Conformity (CoC), hardness charts, and thickness reports meet drawing specifications.

Step 05

Record accept, conditional accept, or reject

Update the routing form with the final disposition. Conditional acceptance requires engineering sign-off for minor deviations that don't affect function.

Step 06

Escalate NCR before assembly release

If parts fail, initiate a Non-Conformance Report (NCR) immediately. Do not release failed parts to the bench Lead or assembly team to avoid downstream costs.

What Supplier Documents Should Be Required for Special Processes?

Technical document audit for outsourced tooling quality verification

Certificate of Conformity

Official CoC linking the part ID, drawing revision, and the specific process performed to the supplier’s quality system.

Plating Thickness Record

Digital or physical measurement log (e.g., X-ray or micron gauge) confirming thickness meets the specified range.

Hardness & Case Depth Report

Mandatory for nitriding or carburizing. Must show effective case depth and surface hardness (HV/HRC) values.

Heat Treatment Certification

Furnace charts or certificates documenting temperature, soak time, and quench cycles for structural integrity.

Dimensional Record

Inspection of CTQ features after the special process to ensure zero distortion or build-up interference.

Sub-supplier Traceability

Evidence of control for Tier-2 suppliers if the primary vendor outsources specific sub-processes like coating or etching.

How Mold Manufacturers Use This Form in Practice

01

Engineering release before subcontracting

Tooling engineers confirm the Drawing Revision, CTQ dimensions, and masking zones. The routing form is attached to the physical parts and the PO before leaving the facility.

02

Supplier confirmation before processing

The external vendor reviews the instructions. Signing the form acknowledges they can meet the tolerances and will provide the required technical documentation (CoC/Hardness charts).

03

Incoming acceptance before bench assembly

Upon return, the bench lead or IQC inspector verifies the parts using the "Acceptance Criteria" section. This is the final gate before parts are integrated into the mold base.

04

NCR, rework, and supplier feedback loop

If parts fail, the "Non-conformance Log" captures the defect. The form travels back to the supplier with the rework instructions, ensuring a closed-loop quality record.

Mold manufacturing CTQ review and outsourced process alignment check

Need a Mold Supplier That Can Align Outsourced Special Processes With Tool Build Requirements?

If you are outsourcing EDM electrodes, chrome plating, or nitriding for mold components, the key issue is not the form itself. The real issue is whether CTQ features, protected surfaces, tolerance risks, and required return documents are defined before parts leave the shop.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a subcontract processing routing and acceptance form?

It is a quality control document used by mold manufacturers to manage parts sent to external vendors for special processes (EDM, plating, nitriding). It tracks part identity, technical instructions, and final quality sign-off.

What fields should be included in an outsourced machining acceptance form?

Essential fields include Mold Number, Part Revision, CTQ dimensions, specific process instructions (like masking zones), a checklist for required supplier documents, and an inspector's disposition section.

What documents should a supplier return for chrome plating or nitriding?

Suppliers must provide a Certificate of Conformity (CoC), plating thickness measurements, hardness test reports, and case depth certifications to prove the process met drawing specifications.

How do you inspect returned EDM electrodes?

Focus on verifying the unique electrode ID, checking the burn faces for chips or oxidation under magnification, ensuring datums are clean, and confirming the profile matches the inspection report.

What are CTQ features in outsourced mold components?

CTQ (Critical-to-Quality) features are high-precision areas such as shutoff faces, sealing lands, sliding fits, and datum pads that directly impact the final mold's function and part quality.

Can a supplier certificate replace incoming inspection?

No. While a CoC provides evidence of the process, incoming inspection is mandatory to verify quantity, check for transport damage, and ensure physical dimensions weren't distorted during treatment.

When should a returned part be conditionally accepted instead of rejected?

Conditional acceptance is used for minor deviations that do not affect part function or mold life (e.g., cosmetic issues on non-functional faces), but it requires formal engineering sign-off.

Is this template suitable for injection mold inserts, cores, and cavities?

Yes, this template is specifically designed for high-value mold components undergoing specialized external processes where technical traceability and CTQ protection are critical.